Skip to main content
LancasterPlumbing Help

Toilets

Toilet repair and replacement

Toilets fail in a handful of predictable ways. Most are cheap parts; the one to take seriously is water leaking under the base, because it rots the floor before you see it.

What it's doing and why

Runs on and off by itself

The flapper at the bottom of the tank no longer seals. Water trickles into the bowl until the tank refills.

Runs constantly

The fill valve doesn't shut off, or the float is set too high and water spills into the overflow tube.

Rocks when you sit

The bolts have loosened or the floor under the toilet is soft. Rocking breaks the wax seal underneath.

Water on the floor at the base

The wax ring has failed, or the bowl is cracked. Water reaches the ceiling below before the floor looks wet.

Clogs every week

A low-flow bowl from an early generation, a partial block in the drain, or a problem further down the line.

Tank sweats in summer

Cold water filling the tank in humid air. Not a leak, but it drips like one.

Safe to check yourself

Two tests before calling

Put a few drops of food coloring in the tank and wait twenty minutes without flushing. Color in the bowl means the flapper is leaking.

Behind the toilet near the floor is a small valve. Turning it clockwise shuts off water to that toilet only, so you can stop a running or overflowing toilet without shutting off the house.

Repair or a new toilet?

Repair makes sense when

  • The bowl and tank are uncracked
  • Only the flapper, fill valve, handle or wax ring has failed
  • It flushes well when it works

Replacement makes sense when

  • The porcelain is cracked
  • It clogs often for no reason found in the drain
  • The flange underneath is broken and the floor needs repair anyway

Ask the company

When a toilet is being replaced

  • Will you check the floor and flange when the old one is up?
  • Does the price include the new supply line and shut-off valve?
  • Do you take away the old toilet?
  • Is the new one the same rough-in size, so it fits the existing drain?

Water off, notes made? Then call.

Say what you saw, where in the house, and since when. The plumbing company on the phone will tell you whether the job is one they do and when they can look at it.

Talk to a plumber about it

For a leak, a blocked drain, a cold shower or a toilet that won't stop running, at a home in or near Lancaster, PA.

Call (717) 555-0129

Calls may be recorded. See how referrals are paid for and the privacy policy.

Call (717) 555-0129