Skip to main content
LancasterPlumbing Help

Water heaters

Water heater repair and replacement in Lancaster, PA

A water heater is usually the largest plumbing purchase a household makes without planning it. A few minutes of looking before you call will tell the plumber whether to bring parts or a new heater.

Illustration: a tank water heater standing on a basement floor beside a brick wall
Illustration

Do this first

If the tank is leaking

Turn off the power or gas to the heater. For electric, switch off its double breaker. For gas, turn the control knob to Off or Pilot.

Close the cold-water valve on the pipe going into the top of the tank. That stops the tank refilling, so the leak is limited to what is already inside.

Put a pan or towels down and move anything stored nearby. Don't open the drain valve to empty the tank unless the plumber asks you to: an old valve sometimes won't close again.

Water spraying from the small pipe on the side is the temperature and pressure relief valve doing its job, or failing. Either way it needs a plumber, and you should not cap or plug that pipe.

Gas or electric

Gas or electric, and how to tell

Gas heater

A metal flue pipe rises from the top into a chimney or out through a wall. There is a gas line with a shut-off handle at the bottom near a control knob.

  • Smell gas near it? Leave the house and call UGI at 800-276-2722 or 911 from outside
  • Flue rusted, loose or sooty: tell the plumber, as venting is part of the job
  • A tank replaced like for like reuses the gas and vent if they are still sound

Electric heater

A thick cable runs into a box on the side or top, and there are one or two removable panels on the side covering the elements.

  • Check the breaker before calling: it may simply have tripped
  • Don't remove the panels yourself: the wiring behind them is live
  • A failed element or thermostat is a common repair on a tank that is otherwise sound

The decision

Repair or replace?

Parts are worth replacing when the tank itself is sound: an igniter, a thermocouple, a gas valve, an element, a thermostat, a relief valve or a dip tube. Once the tank is leaking from its body, no repair holds. The steel liner has rusted through and the only fix is a new heater.

Age matters too. Find the manufacturing date on the label; many brands hide it in the serial number, and the plumber can read it for you. An older tank with sediment noise and a rusty tint in the hot water is often near the end even before it leaks.

Ask the plumber to show you what failed. If the advice is to replace, ask what in particular rules out a repair.

Choosing the new one

Tank or tankless, and what changes

Standard tank

Holds heated water ready to use. Fits where the old one was, usually on the same gas line, vent and wiring. The quickest swap.

Tankless

Heats water as it flows. Hangs on a wall and saves floor space, but often needs a bigger gas line, a new vent through the wall and a dedicated condensate drain.

Heat pump tank

An electric tank that pulls heat from the surrounding air. It needs room around it and cools the basement as it works, which some households welcome in summer.

Same fuel, or switch?

Changing from electric to gas, or the reverse, adds work outside plumbing: a gas line, a vent, or a new electrical circuit. Ask about those before agreeing.

Size

How big the new heater should be

Tanks are sized by how much hot water a household uses in its busiest hour, not by the number of bathrooms alone. Tell the plumber how many people shower in the morning, whether you have a large tub, and whether the dishwasher or washer runs at the same time.

Tankless heaters are sized by flow: how many fixtures run hot at once, and how cold the incoming water is. Winter water in Pennsylvania arrives much colder than summer water, so a unit that keeps up in July may fall behind in January. Ask how it was sized for winter.

Illustration: a tankless water heater mounted on a utility room wall with copper and plastic pipes below
Illustration

Sediment

Hard water and the bottom of the tank

Minerals in the water settle on the tank floor and harden. On a gas tank you hear it as popping. On an electric tank the lower element gets buried and fails early.

Lancaster City Water lists 12 to 15 grains of hardness in the east and south sections of its system and 7 to 10 in the north and west. In the harder areas, ask about flushing the new tank once a year, and about a softener: see hard water and softeners.

Permits

Permits for a water heater swap

In the City of Lancaster, plumbing work goes through the city's mechanical, electrical and plumbing permit application, which asks for the name and license number of a Lancaster City licensed plumber. No work is supposed to start before the permit is issued. Ask the plumber who pulls the permit and when the inspection happens.

In Manheim Township, the township's plumbing and mechanical permit page names water heaters among the jobs it covers. Other townships have their own rules. Permits and licenses has the offices.

On the day

What a replacement disturbs

  • Hot water is off from the time the old tank is drained until the new one is filled and heated
  • The old tank has to come out through the basement stairs or cellar door: clear a path
  • Gas heaters: the gas is shut off at the heater and the burner is relit and tested after
  • Expect the plumber to fill the new tank completely before turning on the heat, then check the vent draws

Ask the company

Questions before you agree to a new heater

  • What size and type are you recommending, and why that size?
  • Does the price include taking away the old tank?
  • Will the gas line, vent, wiring or relief valve pipe need changes?
  • Who pulls the permit, and is the inspection included?
  • Whose warranty covers the heater, and whose covers the installation?
  • Can you put the price, the model and the work in a signed contract?

Water heater questions

Asked about water heaters

Can I relight a gas water heater myself?

Many have relighting steps printed on the label. If you smell gas at any point, stop, leave the house and call UGI. If the pilot lights and goes out again, the thermocouple or control may have failed and a plumber should look.

Why is my hot water rusty but the cold is clear?

Rust only in the hot water usually comes from inside the tank: the liner or the anode rod. If both hot and cold are brown, the cause is more likely in the street mains or old pipes.

Is a tankless heater worth it in an old house?

It depends on the gas line size, where a new vent can exit, and how many hot fixtures run at once. Ask for the full list of changes the house needs, not only the unit.

Cold shower this morning?

Note whether it is gas or electric, roughly how old it is, and whether there is water on the floor. Then call and describe it.

Talk to a plumber about it

For a leak, a blocked drain, a cold shower or a toilet that won't stop running, at a home in or near Lancaster, PA.

Call (717) 555-0129

Calls may be recorded. See how referrals are paid for and the privacy policy.

Call (717) 555-0129